Buyer's guide

PSA vs BGS vs CGC: which grading company is right for your cards?

PSA, Beckett (BGS) and CGC are the three grading companies whose slabs actually move the needle on resale. They use the same 1–10 scale but differ in turnaround, price, presentation and, most importantly, the premium buyers will pay. Here's how they compare in 2026.

At a glance

	PSA	BGS	CGC
Founded	1991 (USA)	1999 (USA)	2000 / cards 2020 (USA)
Scale	1–10, half grades, Gem Mint 10	1–10 with sub-grades, Pristine 10, Black Label 10	1–10 with sub-grades, Pristine 10, Perfect 10
Entry-tier price	~$25 / card (Value)	~$30 / card (Economy)	~$18 / card (Bulk)
Entry-tier turnaround	45–65 business days	30–45 business days	20–30 business days
Sub-grades on label	No (Mint+ qualifier only)	Yes, four sub-grades	Yes, four sub-grades
Slab presentation	Slim, industry-standard	Thick, recessed inner well	Slim, UV-resistant shell
Population report	Largest in the hobby	Strong for vintage sports	Growing fast for modern TCG
Resale premium (modern Pokémon 10)	Highest	Mid (Black Label = highest)	Lower, but closing the gap

Prices and turnaround windows shift quarterly, so always confirm on the grading company's current submission page before sending cards in.

PSA

Professional Sports Authenticator is the volume leader and the default for Pokémon, Magic, and modern sports cards. A PSA 10 typically sells for the highest multiple of raw card value, which is why most flippers and long-term holds default here. The trade-off is queue length: even the Value tier routinely runs 45–65 business days, and bulk submissions require an annual collector's club membership.

Best for: modern Pokémon chase cards, modern sports rookies, anything you intend to resell within a year.

BGS (Beckett)

Beckett is the grader of choice for vintage sports and high-end submissions. Every slab shows four sub-grades (centering, corners, edges, surface) which gives buyers far more information than a single PSA number. A BGS 9.5 Gem Mint is roughly equivalent to a PSA 10 in most categories; a BGS 10 Pristine is rarer and commands a premium; the BGS Black Label 10 (perfect 10s across all four sub-grades) is the rarest slab in the hobby and routinely outsells PSA 10s by multiples.

Best for: vintage cards, high-grade vintage sets, and any card where you're chasing a Black Label or want sub-grade transparency.

CGC

CGC moved from comics into trading cards in 2020 and has grown aggressively, now grading more modern Pokémon than BGS. Its entry tiers are the cheapest of the three majors and turnaround is consistently the fastest, which makes it the sensible choice for bulk modern submissions where the cost per card matters more than the ultimate resale ceiling. CGC slabs include sub-grades and a Perfect 10 designation analogous to the BGS Black Label.

Best for: bulk modern submissions, sealed graded packs, anything where speed and cost-per-card matter more than the last 10% of resale value.

Which should you buy?

If you're collecting graded singles rather than submitting your own, the answer is simpler: buy the slab whose population report and condition you actually trust. PSA 10s are the most liquid; a BGS 9.5 with strong sub-grades is often a better card for the same money; a CGC 10 of a modern chase card is frequently the value play.

Every graded single in our Vault is from PSA, BGS or CGC. No off-brand slabs, no re-holders.

FAQ